From custom cookies to sweet trays and take-home treats, The Unconventional Kitchen bakes with
care and cause. Whether you’re planning a wedding, marking a milestone, or simply want something special to share, we’ll help you create a dessert experience that’s both personal and effortless. Every order supports Vincentian’s mission of service and hospitality across Pittsburgh.
Bakery Options
Indulge in the unique creations of Unconventional Kitchen’s Bakery! Explore a vast selection of delicious and creative baked goods perfect for any occasion. We cater to all your sweet cravings, using only the finest ingredients to craft unforgettable treats. We believe everyone deserves a delightful experience, and we're dedicated to making your gathering truly special.
Fresh Ingredients
At The Unconventional Kitchen, each pastry and sweet is created with care, starting from hand-selected ingredients chosen for their freshness and flavor. Everything is baked in-house, allowing us to give every recipe the time and attention it deserves. From the first bite to the very last, our desserts are designed to surprise and delight with texture, taste, and creativity. Planning a celebration or need something custom? Call us at 412.337.1721—we’d love to help make your gathering unforgettable.
Photo gallery
Posted on gina simonTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jeremiah was great to work with! We used The Unconventional Kitchen to cater our family Christmas dinner and it was absolutely wonderful. The food was delicious, beautifully prepared, and truly made the holiday feel special. Everything was ready on time and made hosting so easy and stress-free. Our whole family loved the meal and I received so many compliments. Highly recommend—this will definitely be our go-to for future family gatherings and holidays!Posted on Lauren GreiderTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I am the catering coordinator for a local firm, and this past week was our first time ordering from Unconventional Kitchen. They arrived right on time, and the set up was quick! Everyone was impressed by the quality and taste of the food, especially the salad and cranberry chicken! Jeremiah's service was courteous, friendly and efficient, and we hope for another opportunity to order from them again! They were excellent!Posted on Michelle BulgerTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I ordered the Thanksgiving meal this year, and it couldn't have been more perfect. Pick up was easy, packaging was great and the heating instructions were clear and easy to understand. Most importantly, the food was delicious! Generous portions, and all went home happy with leftovers! The cookies we ordered for dessert were also devoured!! I am never disappointed with my orders from the Unconventional Kitchen, and this Thanksgiving meal made the whole family happy! THANK YOU! I will order again and again!Posted on Bethany OsikowiczTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Jeremiah and his team were absolutely amazing to work with! Jeremiah went the extra mile with every detail for our October wedding! Everyone was gushing about the food! I would definitely recommend working with them for any catering event!Posted on nancy harterTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I was looking for a catering company for a small group holiday party (25). I ultimately selected Unconventional Kitchen for the event. Jeramiah Freeland contacted me quickly after I submitted an easy online request. Jeramiah's ideas were perfect, and I didn't change anything. Guests at the party raved over the food, and ample portions were provided. I chose to have the food delivered (pickup option was also offered); the driver was organized, prompt and courteous. I will definitely work with Jeramiah again.Posted on Alissa WalkerTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. The unconventional kitchen and Jen have the most amazing skills when it comes to art and food. Jen’s skills with designing Cookies and Sweet treats is just outstanding I have never been disappointed The Roblox cookies for my son seventh birthday were a hit Match my cake perfectly!! I recommend Jen at the unconventional kitchen hands down any day!Posted on Tonya EdingerTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. We had such a wonderful experience working with Unconventional Kitchen! From start to finish, Jeremiah was timely, helpful, and incredibly friendly. He went the extra mile to ensure everything ran smoothly, and his professionalism truly stood out. The food was absolutely delicious—my client and their guests are still raving about it! If you’re looking for a caterer who combines excellent service with unforgettable flavors, I highly recommend Unconventional Kitchen.Posted on Michelle KowalskiTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Alissa was amazing helping us plan the menu for our daughter's wedding shower. She took the time to get to know our vision for the shower and not only made recommendations but added some special requests by the bride. The food was so delicious and she displayed it beautifully. All of the guests raved about the food!Posted on Stacy SweeneyTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. My family used Unconventional Kitchen last week for my Mom's 90th birthday party at Vincentian Assisted Living and they did a top notch job and stayed within our budget. We wanted appetizers and salads and Alissa worked with me to determine the best menu choices that would work well with our Mom's dietary needs while still satisfying our party guests. I was able to pick up the food from their catering space and everything we needed was there including the utensils, pans and chafers and fuel to keep the food warm. The food was delicious and our guests were commenting on what an interesting and tasty variety we had. I had also attended a fundraiser for Vincentian last year where Unconventional Kitchen had done the catering onsite and I had the same positive experience. Highly recommend Unconventional Kitchen for your catering needs.Posted on Melissa RothertTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I placed a custom order from Jen at The Unconventional Kitchen, and she did an AMAZING job! Not only was she helpful and accommodating to my request, but she also brought my vision to life! This is a great idea to bring to a wedding for the Pittsburgh cookie table, a graduation party, showers you name it! I couldn't recommend The Unconventional Kitchen enough!